Black hat SEO is any tactic designed to trick Google rather than help the people searching. White hat SEO is everything else: building a site that deserves to rank, then making it easy for Google to see that. The difference matters most to small businesses, because they are the ones most often sold black hat tactics without being told.
This guide explains what each looks like now, how to spot black hat work in a proposal, and what to do if it has already been done to your site.
Why black hat SEO still gets sold
Because it sometimes works, for a while. A burst of paid links or a few hundred thin location pages can push a site up for months. The invoice gets paid, the report looks good, and the bill for the shortcut arrives later, usually after the contract has ended.
Google has also become much better at catching it. Its spam policies were expanded in March 2024 to cover scaled content abuse, expired domain abuse and site reputation abuse, and its link spam updates are built to neutralise paid links rather than reward them. Tactics that worked in 2015 are now more likely to stall a site than lift it.
Black hat techniques to recognise
- Buying links or link packages. “50 high-authority backlinks for R2,500” is the classic. Paid links that pass ranking value break Google’s link spam policy, and they usually come with exact-match anchor text that is easy to detect.
- Private blog networks. Networks of sites that exist only to link to clients. Cheap to run, and easy for Google to map.
- Scaled content. Hundreds of near-identical pages (“plumber Bellville”, “plumber Durbanville”) or mass-produced AI articles published to catch searches rather than help anyone.
- Keyword stuffing and hidden text. Repeating a phrase until the page reads like a ransom note, or hiding it in white text.
- Cloaking and sneaky redirects. Showing Google one page and visitors another.
- Fake reviews and rating schema. Invented testimonials, or star ratings added to structured data with no real reviews behind them.
- Expired domain abuse. Buying an old domain with good links and repurposing it to pass that strength to an unrelated site.
What white hat SEO looks like
- A technically sound site. Fast, crawlable, mobile-friendly and cleanly structured. The free SEO audit checklist covers the basics.
- Content written for the searcher. Pages that answer the question better than the alternatives, written by someone who knows the subject. That is what Google’s EEAT guidelines describe.
- Links that were earned. Mentions from suppliers, associations, local press and industry sites, because there was a reason to link.
- Honest local signals. A complete Google Business Profile, consistent details across directories and real reviews. The local SEO guide walks through it.
- Accurate structured data. Schema that describes what is actually on the page, and nothing more.
It is slower. It is also the only version that compounds instead of unravelling.
How to spot black hat work in a proposal
- Guaranteed rankings, or “page one in 30 days”.
- A fixed number of backlinks a month, priced per link.
- Vague answers when you ask where the links will come from.
- Large batches of location or keyword pages with the same text.
- Reports full of rankings for phrases nobody searches.
- Reluctance to give you access to your own Search Console, Analytics or hosting.
The guide to choosing an SEO company has a longer list of questions to ask before you sign anything.
If it has already been done to your site
This is common, and it is rarely the business owner’s fault. The signs include a slow slide in Google while Bing still ranks you well, a backlink profile full of irrelevant or foreign sites, or a manual action notice in Search Console.
- Check Search Console first. Look under Security and Manual actions. A manual action needs fixing and a reconsideration request. Most link problems never get one; Google simply discounts the links, along with some of its trust in the site.
- Audit your backlinks. Export them from Search Console or an SEO tool and look for patterns: paid directories, link networks, exact-match anchors.
- Remove what you can, then disavow the rest. Ask site owners to take links down where possible, and use the disavow tool for obvious paid or spam links. Use it carefully: disavowing good links can hurt.
- Clean up on-site shortcuts. Delete or merge thin pages, rewrite stuffed copy and remove any schema that isn’t true.
- Build the white hat foundations. Recovery is not a switch. It is what happens as the site earns trust again.
Expect months, not weeks. While you wait, it is worth understanding how AI search reads your content too: see what is GEO.
The short version
If a tactic only works because Google hasn’t noticed it yet, it is black hat. If it would still make sense with no search engines at all, it is white hat. The second kind is slower and costs more up front, and it is the only kind that keeps paying.
Rather have someone clean it up?
If your site has a messy link history, or you are not sure what a previous provider did, NoGravy, Lindsay’s SEO consultancy, starts with a fixed-price Site Audit that covers exactly that. More about NoGravy.

